cens logo

Tsinghua Unigroup of China to Buy 25% Stake in Two More Taiwanese Chip Assemblers

Such acquisitions seen to bring ample capital without management takeover

Dec 16, 2015 | By CENS

news-photoTsinghua Unigroup is aggressively buying into Taiwan's semiconductor industry.
Tsinghua Unigroup of mainland China announced on Dec. 11 to acquire a 24.9 percent holding in Siliconware Precision Industries Co., Ltd. (SPIL) and a 25 percent stake in ChipMOS Technologies (Bermuda) Ltd. for total cost of NT$68.8 billion (US$2.02 billion) in a private placement each offered by the two Taiwanese companies.

This marks another of Tsinghua's acquisitions of shares in Taiwanese chip assemblers after signing a deal to acquire a quarter stake in Power Technology Inc. (PTI) for NT$19.4 billion (US$587.87 million). SPIL, PTI and ChipMOS are reportedly the island's No.2, No. 3 and No.4 chip assemblers.

Tsinghua is expected to submit the three partial acquisition deals to the Investment Commission of Taiwan's Ministry of Economic Affairs (MOEA) in late January next year for approval.

Tsinghua's acquisitions are generally welcome by the targeted companies for what the investor brings: ample capital instead of management takeover.

For SPIL, the acquisition by Tsinghua is more than just a matter of capital. The acquisition of SPIL shares came amid corporate battle between SPIL and Advanced Semiconductor Engineering Inc. (ASE), reportedly Taiwan's No.1 chip assembler. SPIL has said that ASE had been trying to maliciously acquire its shares with the view to take over its management right. To fend off such incursion, SPIL Chairman W.B. Lin invited the Foxconn Technology Group to take a stake. However, SPIL's foreign institutional shareholders vetoed the invitation in an extraordinary meeting held on Oct. 15 to accept ASE regardless of the strong support from minor shareholders and the company's employees for the chairman's move.

The frustrated Lin then soon organized an investment company with the company's allies to find other interested suitors to take on ASE. The investment company finally decided to invite mainland Chinese investors, which are restricted by Taiwan's regulations as pure shareholders in local chip companies.  

Tsinghua's acquisition unseats ASE to become SPIL's biggest shareholder, whereby the new shares SPIL offered to Tsinghua has diluted ASE's ownership in SPIL to 18.77 percent from 24.99 percent.

SPIL's deal with Tsinghua has caught everyone off guard, especially ASE, who has remained reticent about the deal.

Maximize Corporate Interest
Denying the deal is designed to offset ASE's influence in the company, Lin says that the cooperation with Tsinghua is done to maximize the interest of the company's shareholders. He notes that the company usually offers discounted shares to investors in most private placements, but Tsinghua has been offered shares at 20 percent premium or NT$55 per share. “I think ASE should sign off on this deal,” he says.

Lin points out that the private placement offered to Tsinghua will likely turn Tsinghua's ever-increasing semiconductor subsidiaries worldwide into SPIL's customers in addition to helping his company fortify its existing customer base.

He says the company will use 80 percent of the proceeds from Tsinghua's investment on its employees and operational projects in Taiwan and the rest on its operations in mainland China and elsewhere.

Taiwan's industry executives are really impressed by the significant size of the capital that Tsinghua has invested in the three Taiwanese chip assemblers. Among them is chairman of Pegatron Corp. and the current chairman of the Taipei Computer Association, T.H. Tung, who points out that mainland China is using its huge market as bargaining chip to sway competitors to transplant to and share technologies with China, which is aggressively developing its homegrown semiconductor industry.

Hostility Ill-advised
“If Taiwan's tech industries refuse to work with mainland investors, they could lose access to the mainland's vast market,” he says. He suggests that Taiwan's tech manufacturers need to tone down their hostile attitude towards the mainland so as to view objectively their competency and their mainland Chinese partners.

Tung points out that it is the relatively low price-earning ratio (E/P ratio) of Taiwan's listed tech companies that draw investors from the mainland and the world to buy into Taiwan's tech companies. Such ratio is only seven to 10 for Taiwan's tech stocks, compared with 20 to 30 for the mainland's tech stocks, he notes. “If we do not suspect foreign investors of invading Taiwan's tech industries like Foxconn and Pegatron by taking advantage of the low P/E ratio, why would we suspect the mainland's investors of encroaching on Taiwan's tech companies by doing the same thing as the foreign investors?” he asks.

Tung points out that it makes sense for the mainland to develop its homegrown semiconductor industry given that its import of semiconductors far exceed its import of oil in terms of revenue. “If Taiwanese manufacturers refuse to work with the mainland's manufacturers, the mainland's vast market will sooner or later develop its own technology for an indigenous semiconductor industry, to put Taiwanese manufacturers at competitive disadvantage,” he warns.

R&D Success
The TCA Chairman notes that many mainland Chinese tech manufacturers have achieved considerable success in R&D without government funding. For instance, many mainland Chinese tech companies now approach his company with cooperation offers instead of groveling for permission to visit the company as previously whenever the company has introduced something new, suggesting the mainland's manufacturers have built enough R&D strength to cooperate with Taiwan's counterparts on equal footing.

Executives of Taiwan's top semiconductor companies point out that the cash-rich mainland Chinese semiconductor manufacturers with aggressive global plans need not choose to work with their Taiwanese counterparts, which are mostly struggling for new capital and new markets to overcome developmental bottlenecks they face now. They worry if the mainland's makers turn to South Korean tech firms, Taiwan's arch competitors on many fields of global markets, Taiwan's tech companies will have to overcome even tougher challenges. “Will Taiwan's tech firms be better off by shutting out mainland's investors? This question deserves our consideration,” says a tech insider.

However, Director General Zichen Du of the government-financed Industrial Economics and Knowledge (IEK) has openly objected to Tsinghua's acquisition of SPIL, commenting the share sale is tantamount to selling Taiwan's interest to the mainland from the viewpoint that SPIL is simply selling a stake to Tsinghua to ward off ASE, not for business expansion.

But Du advocates TSMC's plan to open an eight-inch wafer fab in Nanjing to make 16-nanometer chips and MediaTek Corp.'s plan to to sell a partial stake to mainland Chinese investors.

Naysayer
P.J. Liu, a research fellow at the non-profit Taiwan Institute of Economic Research, warns that Tsinghua will be able to rapidly boost its presence on the global semiconductor market by buying into the three Taiwanese chip assemblers, which own expertise in memory-chip, logic-chip, and high-end chip packaging and testing, respectively. “But that would be a shame to Taiwan's semiconductor industry,” she stresses.

She analyzes that Tsinghua's acquisitions will make Taiwan's chip assemblers unable to work together to compete on the global market, where the island is the No.1 supplier of chip packaging and testing services with a share of approximately 50 percent, far leading the 15 percent estimated to be captured by the distant No.2 mainland China by the end of 2015. She notes that without team effort, ASE alone can hold only 18 percent.

The research fellow says that ASE just wants to team up with SPIL against the rising mainland China red supply chain, from which ASE feels competitive threat after reports that the mainland's Jiangsu Changjiang Electronics Technology Co., Ltd. is poised to challenge ASE for Apple orders with its newly equipped system-in-package (SIP) capability.

Opposed to Liu and Du's perspective on Tsinghua's acquisition deals in Taiwan, Hua Nan Securities Investment Management Co., Ltd. Chairman H.S. Tsu feels upbeat about cooperating between the mainland Chinese company and Taiwan's manufacturers in consideration that the leading status of Taiwan's semiconductor industry on the global market will sooner or later be replaced by the mainland's rising supply chains. Holding stakes in Taiwanese firms would actually prompt such mainland manufacturers to think twice before recklessly expanding their capacity, he notes.

Pro-Tsinghua
ProMOS Chairman S.J. Chen points out that his company has no qualms about Tsinghua's investment on grounds that the two companies complement each other in expertise and share the same business idea not to mention that many of Tsinghua's reinvested businesses in chip packaging and testing, and liquid crystal display (LCD) sectors are his company's existing customers.

The two companies, he adds, will work together on such fields as LCD drive ICs, micro electromechanical system (MEMS) and Internet of Things (IoT).

Chen discloses that TSMC's Nanjing plan advocates Tsinghua to accelerate its acquisition of his company's stocks.

Some Taiwanese industry executives point out that Tsinghua's acquisitions of Taiwan's chip assemblers underscore China's policy to set up integrated capability of its semiconductor industry by helping Tsinghua make overseas acquisitions, and Semiconductor Manufacturing International Corp. (SMIC), the mainland's No.1 homegrown chipmaker, develop advanced processing technologies.

M.B. Chang, executive secretary general of the Investment Commission, points out that the chances for the three Tsinghua deals to pass the commission's approval at once is unlikely since holding three of the island's top-four chip assemblers by a mainland company could upset the status quo of the global IC packaging and testing industry. 


Industry In-Focus

Latest Chinese-U.S. Trade Talks Mark Chance of Higher-Level Meetings and Ease Market Tensions</h2>

Latest Chinese-U.S. Trade Talks Mark Chance of Higher-Level Meetings and Ease Market Tensions

Jan 14, 2019

The world waited with bated breath as Chinese and U.S. representatives met during this week to deliberate over whether the trade war would finally come to a reasonable conclusion. Throughout the entirety of the trade war early last year, from escalation to the tentative 90-day truce borne from the G20 Summit in Argentina between President Xi Jinping and U.S. counterpart President Donald Trump...


Taiwan Firms Kicks off 2019 at ArabPlast </h2>

Taiwan Firms Kicks off 2019 at ArabPlast

Jan 10, 2019

The biannual ArabPlast 2019 is marked as the most indicative benchmark as the largest trade expo for plastics, petrochemicals and rubber industry in the MENA region. The show kicked off on Jan. 5, attracting 336 exhibitors from 27 countries. Taiwanese exhibitors also attended, led by Taiwan Association of Machinery Industry in a 34-member strong delegation, a size just shy of China and India. ...


ARTC Teams Up With 18 Companies to Form Self-Driving Vehicle Union</h2>

ARTC Teams Up With 18 Companies to Form Self-Driving Vehicle Union

Dec 28, 2018

November 20 marks a huge milestone in Taiwan’s self-driving industry. The Automotive Research & Testing Center (ARTC) joined hands with 18 brands, including Acer ITS Inc., Global UniTek, Shin Wei Automotive Industrial and others of Taiwan’s top-to-bottom industrial chain to form the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Alliance. Their overall aim is to shore up support for a new, innovative operation m...



Industry Reports

Latest Chinese-U.S. Trade Talks Mark Chance of Higher-Level Meetings and Ease Market Tensions</h2>

Latest Chinese-U.S. Trade Talks Mark Chance of Higher-Level Meetings and Ease Market Tensions

Jan 14, 2019

The world waited with bated breath as Chinese and U.S. representatives met during this week to deliberate over whether the trade war would finally come to a reasonable conclusion. Throughout the entirety of the trade war early last year, from escalation to the tentative 90-day truce borne from the G20 Summit in Argentina between President Xi Jinping and U.S. counterpart President Donald Trump...


ARTC Teams Up With 18 Companies to Form Self-Driving Vehicle Union</h2>

ARTC Teams Up With 18 Companies to Form Self-Driving Vehicle Union

Dec 28, 2018

November 20 marks a huge milestone in Taiwan’s self-driving industry. The Automotive Research & Testing Center (ARTC) joined hands with 18 brands, including Acer ITS Inc., Global UniTek, Shin Wei Automotive Industrial and others of Taiwan’s top-to-bottom industrial chain to form the Autonomous Vehicle Industry Alliance. Their overall aim is to shore up support for a new, innovative operation m...


An Alliance Between Ford and VW Could be Announced as Early as Next Year</h2>

An Alliance Between Ford and VW Could be Announced as Early as Next Year

Dec 11, 2018

There is news of a far-reaching alliance between Ford Motor and Volkswagen, according to those familiar to the matter, reported CNBC. The two world’s largest automakers plan to announce the alliance next January, a partnership that would encompass sharing assembly plants in the U.S. to avoid new the wave of tariffs, joint marketing and distribution as well as product development, possibly on t...



Supplier News

Antrc Industrial Corp. offers bumpers, parts, decoration strips, skid plates, radiator, radiator grill, headlights and rear lights and will be exhibiting at Automechanika Shanghai to tap into the Asian markets. (photo courtesy of Antrc Industrial Corp.)

Antrc Industrial Corp. Aims for High-End Auto Parts Industry for Asian Markets

Dec 05, 2018

Antrc Industrial Corp. focuses on manufacturing plastic parts, metal parts and other automotive parts in the aftermarket industry. The firm can roll out parts and products that match with customers’ needs and the industry pulse in this changing and competitive market. Having deep roots in the AM industry, Antrc can deliver with its complete supply chain, from designing, molding making and finally...

ANTRC INDUSTRIAL CORP.


NHC and YangPo products satisfy demands for different automobiles. (photographed by Tseng Lung-nan)

Brake Maker Nan Hoang Rides on Biz Upswing to Offer More Clients the Best

Dec 04, 2018

For more than five decades, Nan Hoang Traffic Instrument Co., Ltd (NHC) has been one of the major manufacturers of specialty vehicle friction materials in Taiwan and around the world. Chairman Austin Cheng has been carrying out their “double-arrow developing plan” for this year. In one aspect, through its private label YangPo, NHC aims to adopt a more effective marketing strategy for selling own-...

NAN HOANG TRAFFIC INSTRUMENT CO., LTD.


Intime offers high-quality performance brake calipers. (photo courtesy of Intime)

Intime's Products Sought-after by Professionals Worldwide

Dec 04, 2018

Founded in 2013, Intime Auto Parts Co., Ltd., specializes in making performance brake calipers and performance shock absorber systems. Intime takes pride of its “n&b performance” series. The firm's n&b ceramic brake pads, which are made of low metallic NAO material, is capable of functioning without damaging the brake discs. Also notable is that the brake dust can be removed easily from the al...

INTIME AUTO PARTS CO., LTD.



Insiders' Views

Megvii Technology Founder and CEO Tang Wenbin

Part 1 Megvii Technology Founder Interview: Face++ AI Facial Recognition sets eye on Asia, starting with Taiwan

Sep 07, 2018

Using facial recognition to remove security checks and recognizing criminals sounds like technological applications out of a movie, though much of it is already implemented in everyday life. Having been founded for only seven years, Megvii Technology Limited, or more commonly known for its facial recognition and AI application Face++, owns critical technology by combining both, and now, recently ...

FOXCONN TECHNOLOGY


Megvii Technology Founder Interview Part 2: Face++ AI Facial Recognition sets eye on Asia, starting with Taiwan</h2>

Megvii Technology Founder Interview Part 2: Face++ AI Facial Recognition sets eye on Asia, starting with Taiwan

Sep 07, 2018

Tang Wenbin, founder and CEO of Megvii Technology, will be visiting Taiwan next week, but accepted an overseas interview with Economic Daily News on Sept. 6. This is the second installment of the interview. Aiming for a complete application; forming a city’s “brain” Q: What are the goals and strategy for the next phase? A: When the company first started off, we had to find a way to impl...

FOXCONN TECHNOLOGY


MPN's Editor-at-large Provides Holistic, In-depth Insights into U.S. Market for Powersports</h2><p class='subtitle'>Industry veteran suggests Taiwanese suppliers establish market presence as priority</p>

MPN's Editor-at-large Provides Holistic, In-depth Insights into U.S. Market for Powersports

Industry veteran suggests Taiwanese suppliers establish market presence as priority

May 24, 2018

One of the concurrent events held during the 13th Taiwan International Motorcycle Industry Show (Motorcycle Taiwan 2018), the seminar titled “Turning New U.S. Powersports Business Opportunities” was rounded off with overwhelming acclaim from the audience as a resounding success, mostly thanks to the excellent quality of the lecturers invited, all of whom are seasoned veterans and experts at high ...



Exhibition Highlights

Taiwan Firms Kicks off 2019 at ArabPlast </h2>

Taiwan Firms Kicks off 2019 at ArabPlast

Jan 10, 2019

The biannual ArabPlast 2019 is marked as the most indicative benchmark as the largest trade expo for plastics, petrochemicals and rubber industry in the MENA region. The show kicked off on Jan. 5, attracting 336 exhibitors from 27 countries. Taiwanese exhibitors also attended, led by Taiwan Association of Machinery Industry in a 34-member strong delegation, a size just shy of China and India. ...


2018 AAPEX Post-Show Report</h2>

2018 AAPEX Post-Show Report

Dec 24, 2018

The 2018 edition of Automotive Aftermarket Products Expo (AAPEX) kicked off from Oct. 30 to Nov. 1 at Sands Expo Center; a total of 6,269 exhibitors came from 43 countries/regions, a 4% growth compared to last year’s figures, using up over 5,000 booths. Organizers estimate that over 162,000 professional buyers from approximately 135 countries visited the largest show of its kind in the North Amer...


Source: show organizer

The 19th Fastener Trade Show Suzhou - China's leading one-stop purchasing platform for fasteners, machinery and supporting products

Dec 05, 2018

As a large international fastener specialized exhibition, the 19th Fastener Trade Show Suzhou will connect the upstream and downstream of fastener manufacturing industry. Focusing on end users and building a global fastener trade platform are the highlights of the show. The 17th Fastener Trade Show Suzhou, successfully held during 26-28 October 2017, was highly praised by exhibitors and visito...